European employment regulation has been repeatedly identified by policymakers as too stringent resulting in policy recommendations aimed at a more flexible labour market. This diagnosis has been reaffirmed, particularly by international policymakers, in the post-2008 economic and jobs crisis with high employment protection regarded as harmful for employment, responsible for boosting precarious jobs and likely to result in social costs including unemployment. The labour market reforms pushed by the European Commission after 2010 targeted reducing employment protection legislation (EPL) with the dual expectation that they will revive “job creation in sclerotic labour markets while tackling segmentation and adjustment at the same time” (European Commission 2012, 4).

In this paper the authors argue that the current—overwhelmingly deregulatory—reform agenda is too narrowly specified. Above all, the debate needs to be turned around from the focus on de-regulation to the role of re-regulation for inclusive labour markets. With the focus on costs-related disincentives for employers to use standard forms of employment, the dominant debate fails to recognise a more complex set of problems that may put groups of workers at risk of exclusion.

Table of contents

Full text

Related content

Valeria Pulignano

Work in deregulated labour markets: a research agenda for precariousness

This Working Paper tackles two questions: what counts as work within a deregulated labour market; and what are the implications for the study of precariousness? The paper addresses the traditional dichotomy between paid and unpaid work which obscures how unpaid activities often undercut paid employment. In this light, it suggests a new way of... Find out more

Drifting into labour market insecurity? Labour market reforms in Europe after 2010

This working paper examines the impact of fiscal austerity on EU labour market policies. Using a case study approach, it examines: the extent of change in unemployment benefit levels and policies; the effect of this on groups of workers; and whether the logic of activation policies has shifted. Overall, the broad direction of policy has not altered... Find out more

Myths of employment deregulation: how it neither creates jobs nor reduces labour market segmentation

This book looks at the effects of changes in employment regulation on levels and forms of employment in nine EU countries (Spain, Italy, Estonia, Slovakia, Poland, Germany, France, Denmark, and the UK). It demonstrates that reducing employment protection has brought neither labour market nor economic benefits. Moreover, post-crisis changes were... Find out more

Labour market developments and employment policies in south-east Europe

SEER Journal for Labour and Social Affairs in Eastern Europe SEER, Volume 19 (2016), Issue 1, ISSN: 1435-2869, ISSN online: 1435-2869, https://doi.org/10.5771/1435-2869-2016-1 Browse Volumes and Issues: SEER Journal for Labour and Social Affairs in Eastern Europe Find out more

Gabriele Piazza, Martin Myant

Italy's labour market reforms of 2012: did they reduce unemployment?

This Working Paper critically analyses Italy’s labour market reforms of 2012 (Fornero Reform). It focuses especially on a measure designed to cut unemployment and labour-market dualism by reducing the protection against dismissal enjoyed by permanent employees.The main argument of this paper is that labour market reforms focused on promoting... Find out more

Laszlo Horwitz, Martin Myant

Spain’s labour market reforms: the road to employment – or to unemployment?

This working paper looks at recent structural reforms of the Spanish labour market and evaluates them against the government’s stated objectives to reduce unemployment.It concludes that the labour market flexibilisation approach has not helped to reduce unemployment, nor has it contributed to the process of reactivating the long-term unemployed or... Find out more

Thorsten Schulten, Torsten Müller

Back on the agenda: a European minimum wage standard

This policy brief provides a brief but systematic overview of the different minimum wage regimes currently found in the EU as a basis for formulating some potential contours of a European minimum wage policy. Find out more

Chiara Benassi

Political economy of labour market segmentation: agency work in the automotive industry

This paper investigates cross-company variation in the core-periphery configuration of the workforce. The empirical focus is on four automotive plants in Germany, which differ in terms of their organisation of agency work. The comparison reveals that there is no automatic relationship between skills, products and company workforce structure. As... Find out more

Janine Leschke

Has the economic crisis contributed to more segmentation in labour market and welfare outcomes?

This paper analyses whether developments on the labour market and in the welfare system during the economic crisis can be seen as perpetuating the trend towards labour market segmentation or whether the crisis may actually have contributed to containing some of the divisions forged in recent decades. The emphasis is placed on (involuntary) part... Find out more

The Better Regulation agenda: a ‘new deal’ in the building of Europe

Scrutiny of the Better Regulation agenda reveals the European Commission’s use of doublespeak. Feigning a concern for modernisation, simplification and improvement of the quality of Community regulation, the Commission has embarked, with the help of the Council and the tacit approval of the European Parliament, on an insidious enterprise to... Find out more